Old Presbyterian Meeting House

Unveiling the Remarkable Life and Impact of Dr. James Muir: a Prominent Figure in the Old Presbyterian Meeting House’s History

Guardian of Farewell: An Enduring Legacy

In the heart of history-rich Alexandria, an unassuming figure stands tall among the annals of time. Reverend James Muir, D.D., a man whose life wove together faith, leadership, compassion, and historical significance, left an indelible mark on the Old Presbyterian Meeting House and its community. His story, filled with the complexities of his era, serves as a bridge between past and present, offering insights into the intertwining narratives of devotion, history, and the human experience.

Custodian of Faith and History: Reverend James Muir, D.D. (1757-1820)
The Reverend James Muir, D.D. (1757-1820). Image courtesy of the Old Presbyterian Meeting House.

Originating from Scotland to Alexandria’s Heart

Rev. James Muir’s journey began in the verdant landscapes of Scotland, a land known for its rich history and resilient spirit. His path led him across the Atlantic, where he found himself at the helm of the Old Presbyterian Meeting House in Alexandria. As the third minister from 1788 to 1820, Muir’s steadfast dedication to his congregation left an indelible mark. His meticulous documentation is a testament to his unwavering faith and methodical approach, preserving his legacy for generations.

A Pillar of Leadership and Compassion

Rev. Muir’s influence extended far beyond the confines of the pulpit. As a leader in his community, he demonstrated compassion by spearheading Alexandria’s Poor Relief Committee, ensuring the welfare of those in need. Muir held the role of Chaplain at Lodge No. 22, the very lodge Washington belonged to. His position as the local Masonic Lodge chaplain illuminated his dedication to various aspects of life, underscoring his multifaceted character and unwavering commitment to the welfare of his fellow citizens.

Nurturing Minds: A Legacy of Education

Recognizing the transformative power of education, Rev. Muir took on the role of the president of the Alexandria Academy. This commitment to nurturing young minds and advancing knowledge underscored his dedication to progress and intellectual growth. His influence in shaping the minds of future generations continues to echo through time, reminding us of the enduring impact of dedicated educators.

A Testament in the Pages: The Geneva Bible

Among the tangible artifacts bridging the gap between the past and the present, a 1640 Geneva Bible is a poignant symbol of Rev. Muir’s legacy. This historical and spiritual treasure encapsulates his commitment to guiding the congregation’s spiritual journey. With its unique lineage connecting it to his wife and the esteemed Bishop of St. Andrews, this cherished Bible is a tangible link to a man whose influence went beyond his time.

Title Page of the Old Presbyterian Meeting House Geneva Bible, Brought to the Congregation by Reverend James Muir, Third Pastor. Printed in 1640, this Bible Remains an Occasional Companion during Congregational Worship.

Chaplaincy and Ceremonial Significance

Rev. Muir’s role extended to pivotal historical events, further solidifying his place in the tapestry of history. As Chaplain at Washington’s Masonic Lodge, he played a crucial role in the ceremonial laying of the South Cornerstone of the District of Columbia. His guiding prayers lent a profound significance to this moment, linking him to the birth of the nation’s capital.

A segment of Fairfax County Surveyor George Gilpin’s Map of Alexandria, Illustrating Jones Point – The Confluence of Virginia, Maryland, and the District of Columbia, Home to the South Cornerstone of the District of Columbia.

Leading the Nation in Farewell

Rev. Muir’s involvement in honoring George Washington’s legacy was not limited to local funeral services. His leadership extended to the pivotal events that unfolded after Washington’s passing. As the nation mourned, the Meeting House served as a sanctuary of solace under Rev. Muir’s guidance. It provided a setting for public funeral services, where the community could gather, offering their respects to the revered leader.

Guiding the Procession: December 18, 1799

Just four days after George Washington’s passing, on December 18, the remains of the beloved leader found their final resting place at Mount Vernon. The community’s depth of respect and admiration for Washington was reflected in the solemn procession of mourners from Alexandria, a nearby town. Gathering early in the morning, they embarked on a journey spanning over nine miles to pay their final respects.

A Ceremony of Significance

Upon reaching Mount Vernon, an impeccably organized interment ceremony unfolded, orchestrated by Alexandria’s Masonic Lodge No. 22. With Rev. Muir at the helm, the ceremony commenced at three o’clock in the afternoon, continuing until sundown. This dignified yet somber ceremony marked when George Washington’s mortal remains were laid to rest in their final abode. (In 1831, the mortal remains of George Washington, along with those of Martha and other family members, were relocated to the new tomb.) The significance of this event was not lost on the nation, as it marked the end of an era and the legacy of a founding father.

Remembering a Nation’s Loss: George Washington’s Funeral on December 18, 1799

The Role of the Meeting House

During these mournful days, the Old Presbyterian Meeting House was pivotal. Its hallowed walls bore witness to history as it became the setting for public funeral services held in honor of George Washington. Within its embrace, members of the community gathered to remember and pay homage to the life and contributions of the departed leader. The Meeting House stood as a beacon of solace, where people could find unity in their shared grief.

Artist rendering of the first Meeting House, constructed in 1775 and tragically destroyed by fire in 1835, only to be rebuilt in 1837 after being struck by lightning. During the sad days that followed George Washington’s passing, the Old Presbyterian Meeting House played a pivotal role. Its sacred walls stood witness to history, transforming into the setting for public funeral services held in honor of the revered leader, George Washington.

A Deeper Dive: Explore the Commemorative Services

The commemorative services held in honor of George Washington’s passing are a testament to his impact on the nation and its people. Those eager to unearth more about the intricacies of these services—the rituals, the emotions—are invited to embark on a deeper exploration through a dedicated blog post. Through historical accounts, insights into customs of the time, and a profound understanding of how the nation bid farewell to a founding father and esteemed leader, a richer appreciation of these events awaits. For those seeking to pay homage to George Washington’s enduring legacy, the [link] to the blog provides a gateway to history’s embrace.

A Participant in Historic Diplomacy

Rev. Muir’s legacy extends even to the challenging realm of diplomacy. Amid the turmoil of the War of 1812, he found himself at the forefront of surrender negotiations, offering the surrender of Alexandria to British Admiral Cockburn. This act of duty and commitment showcased his dedication to community and history, a reminder that his influence transcended the pulpit.

Symbolic Struggles: A Political Cartoon of Cowering Alexandrians before John Bull, Emblem of Great Britain.

Family and Fellowship: A Life Interwoven

Beyond his ministerial duties, Rev. Muir’s personal life adds layers of complexity to his story. His ownership of an enslaved woman and African American servants sheds light on the societal norms of the time. Living with his wife, Elizabeth Welman Muir, and their four children – Samuel Crichton, Jane Wardlaw, Mary Wardlaw, and Elizabeth Love – in the congregation’s parsonage, the Muir family’s daily life offers a lens through which to view the intricacies of that era.

Remembering Their Legacy

Despite their heartaches and losses, the Muir family’s connection to the Meeting House endured. Daughters Jane Welman Muir and Mary Wardlaw Muir became integral members of the congregation, their memberships noted in church records. The loss of infant children like Mary Frances Wardlaw Muir and Elizabeth Muir served as poignant reminders of the fragility of life in those times.

The Last Chapter

Elizabeth Love Muir (1800-1876) closes the chapter on Muir family interments, her presence recorded without a gravestone. Her inclusion in the Meeting House community resonates with the congregation’s values of fellowship and faith. Her absence of a headstone serves as a poignant reminder of the passage of time and the quiet narratives that often escape the pages of history.

Epilogue: Legacy, Faith, and Reflection

We glimpse a world shaped by faith, history, and personal devotion through the lens of Rev. James Muir and his family. “Guardian of Farewell: Dr. Muir’s Role in Washington’s Funeral” reveals a comprehensive picture of a man, a family, and a community that navigated the challenges and triumphs of their time, leaving behind a legacy that remains woven into the fabric of history. Rev. James Muir, D.D. (1757-1820), a name that resonates through time, serves as a reminder that the threads of history are intertwined with the human spirit.

Honoring Reverend Dr. James Muir: Memorial Plaque adorning the North Wall in the Sanctuary of the Old Presbyterian Meeting House. A Legacy Resting Below: Muir’s Burial 13 Feet Beneath the Pews of the Church’s North Aisle.

Original Gravestone

Sacred to the memory
of departed worth
Reposing beneath this monument
in the assured hope
of a Glorious Resurrection
are the mortal remains
of the
late Rev. JAMES MUIR D.D.
for 31 years and 3 months the faithful Minister
of affectionate people.
Amiable and unobtrusive in his manners
Kind and benevolent in his disposition:
Diligent and unwearied in the discharge
of his pastoral duties.
He died as he lived
an illustrious example of excellency of
that faith once delivered to the saints.
Dr. Muir was a native of Scotland,
but having emigrated to the United States in
his thirty third year, he continued therein,
respected and beloved by all that knew him
until translated by death August 8, 1820.
in the 64th year of his age into that better
world where the wicked cease from troubling and
the weary are at rest
And I hear a voice from Heaven saying until me
write blessed are the dead which died in the Lord from
henceforth; yea, saith the spirit, that they may rest
from their Labour’s, and their works do follow them.

Rev. XIV.13
Preserving Reverend Muir’s Memory: The Engraving Over His Original Burial Site in the Original Meeting House, Relocated and Replaced on the North Wall after the Fire of 1835. Now Resting in the 18th-Century Burial Ground of the Meeting House

Sources of Information

McGroarty, W. B. (1940). The Old Presbyterian Meeting House at Alexandria, VA 1774 – 1874. The William Byrd Press, Inc.

The Alexandria Association. (1956). Our Town 1749-1865 at Gadsby’s Tavern Alexandria, Virginia. The Dietz Printing Company.

Pippenger, W. E. (1992). Tombstone Inscriptions of Alexandria, Virginia: Volume 1. Family Line Publications.

Powell, M. G. (2000). Index by Pippenger, W. E. The History of Old Alexandria, VA, from July 13, 1749 – May 24, 1861. Willow Bend Books.

Dahmann, D. C. (2002). The Roster of Historic Congregational Members of the Old Presbyterian Meeting House. Unpublished.

Dahlmann, D. (2011). Diligent and Unweared in the Discharge of his Duties: The 1805 Diary of the Rev. Dr. James Muir. Minister of the Old Presbyterian Meeting House in Alexandria, Virginia. Editing, Annotations, and Supplementary information by Donald D. Dahlmann. Heritage Books.

Boundary Stones of the District of Columbia. (n.d.). Additional information. Retrieved May 2022, from [URL]

Share on Social Media

By David

Hello. With a passion for bringing history to life, I serve my community as a public historian and cemetery superintendent. My journey has led me to own businesses, conduct Civil War battlefield tours and research Alexandria’s cemeteries.

Since 2015, I have had the privilege of serving as Superintendent of the historic Presbyterian Cemetery and Columbarium, located within Alexandria's Wilkes Street Cemetery Complex. The Presbyterian Cemetery has close ties to the Old Presbyterian Meeting House, situated one mile east, where my family has worshipped for two generations. My parents are laid to rest in this cemetery, which holds a special place in my heart.

Most weekends, you can find me leading tours of the Wilkes Street Cemetery Complex, where thirteen cemeteries are located, with over 35,000 buried. Considered one of the most historic cluster of cemeteries in the United States, I weave my enthusiasm for teaching with the stories of those interred there. I also manage a blog focused on all the cemeteries in Alexandria where the many souls buried across the city are memorialized.

In addition, I'm an active Board Member of both the Alexandria Historical Society and Lee-Fendall House Museum. As part of the Northern Virginia Cemetery Consortium, I diligently preserve endangered burial sites throughout the region.

If Alexandria’s history captivates you, I invite you to join one of my cemetery tours, read my blog on memorializing souls buried across the city’s cemeteries, or connect with me on social media. I find joy and purpose in bringing Alexandria’s rich past to life and serving my community.

Verified by MonsterInsights