Presbyterian Cemetery: History, Distinguished Stories, and Sources

Overview

This page tells the story of the cemetery itself: its origins in the yellow fever epidemic of 1803, its establishment on Spring Garden Farm, and its boundaries today. The biographies of the people buried here are on three companion pages, arranged by surname, and the sources behind all of them are listed in the Sources of Information section at the end of this page.

One of the thirteen cemeteries in the Wilkes Street Cemetery Complex and among its earliest Protestant burial grounds, the Presbyterian Cemetery covers 7.68 acres across three parcels on Hamilton Lane. It illustrates Alexandria’s shift from in-town churchyards to larger cemeteries beyond the town limits.

Discover the Lives Behind the Stones

More than 2,400 people rest in its historic seven-acre burial ground, many of them central to the city’s civic, military, and cultural history. Among them are Revolutionary War figures Capt. William Harper and Mayor Dennis Ramsay; War of 1812 naval hero John Thomas Newton; Mayor and Congressman Lewis McKenzie; and Civil War veterans including the McKnight brothers and Samuel R. Johnston, the reconnaissance officer whom “Lost Cause” writers later blamed for Lee’s defeat at Gettysburg. They also include Cold War Soviet spy William Weisband and members of prominent local families such as the Jamiesons, Muirs, Vowells, and Cazenoves.

Their stories are told in a growing collection of mini-biographies, arranged in three alphabetical sections:


Origins and Early Burials (1803–1809)

The cemetery’s origins lie in Alexandria’s yellow fever epidemic of 1803, which claimed 197 lives and overwhelmed the town’s churchyards. The Rev. Dr. James Muir, pastor of the Presbyterian Church of Alexandria, described the outbreak in a sermon later published with an appendix on “the extent of the mortality” and the town’s public health response.

In the epidemic’s wake, Alexandria, then part of the District of Columbia, passed an ordinance on March 27, 1804, prohibiting “the opening or allotting of any new burying ground for the interment of human bodies within the limits of the Corporation.” The act set fines for violations and required the removal of bodies buried after its passage, forcing the town’s congregations to look for burial grounds outside its boundaries.

By 1806, the congregations were working together. On June 26, 1806, George Deneale, senior warden of Christ Church, and Jonathan Swift placed an advertisement in the Alexandria Gazette seeking a burial site for four congregations. That cooperation shaped what became the Wilkes Street Cemetery Complex.

Early Interments at Spring Garden Farm

Presbyterians were burying their dead at Spring Garden Farm well before they formally acquired the land. The Health Office reported six burials in the “Presbyterian” burying ground in August and September 1803, at the height of the epidemic. A gravestone bears this out: it records the death of George Kilton on October 18, 1803, and the burial of his son George in November 1802, showing that the site was in use even before the 1804 ordinance.

Other gravestones survive with dates as early as 1803. The oldest date in the cemetery, 1775, belongs to Martha Bryan McKnight, whose name is carved on the box tomb of her husband, William McKnight, made after his death in 1812. She died in Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, before the family moved to Alexandria, and whether her remains lie here is unknown.

Formal Establishment

On June 22, 1809, a committee of church members, including Thomas Vowell, James Irwin, Joseph Riddle, Richard Veitch, Hugh Smith, Joseph Deane, Andrew Jamieson, Alexander McKenzie, and the late Joseph Harper, signed a lease with Philip G. Marsteller (son of Lt. Col. Philip Marsteller, d. 1803) and his wife, Christiana Cooper Marsteller (c. 1774–1815), for a “square of ground” at Spring Garden Farm.

The purchase was completed by deed on February 6, 1813, when the “Presbyterian Congregation of the Town of Alexandria” acquired the land for $450 (Fairfax County Deed Book M2, page 311). Christiana Marsteller was later buried in the cemetery, likely beside her husband in 41:29 or in Section 42.

This deed provides one of the earliest surviving legal descriptions of the Wilkes Street Cemetery Complex, situating the Presbyterian tract “on the south side of Gibbon Lane, north side of Franklin Lane, west side of Hamilton Lane, and east side of Mandeville Lane.”


Survey Map and Boundaries

An 1890 survey by Howell & Greenhough of Washington, D.C., shows the cemetery’s burial plots extending across Hooff’s Run, and A. B. Garrett of Alexandria updated the plan in 1939. The bridge and terraces mapped below the bank of the Run were never built; they appear to have been an unrealized idea for better access between the east and west sections. The land itself was cemetery property, although no separate deed for the western portion has been located.

1890 survey map of the Presbyterian Cemetery showing burial plots on both sides of Hooff’s Run
An 1890 survey map of the Presbyterian Cemetery shows burial plots extending across Hooff’s Run. The section on the upper right, across the Run, later became part of what is now the Alexandria African American Heritage Park.

Boundary Description

Today, the Presbyterian Cemetery consists of three parcels:

  • 600 Hamilton Lane — 322,549 sq ft (approx. 7.40 acres). This principal parcel contains the active burial grounds, with about seven acres enclosed by fencing. Portions of this tract also extend onto the west bank of Hooff’s Run.
  • 580 Holland Lane — 1,139 sq ft (approx. 0.03 acres). Located on the west bank of Hooff’s Run.
  • 700 Holland Lane — 11,061 sq ft (approx. 0.25 acres). Also located on the west bank of Hooff’s Run.

The original burial tract encompassed roughly seven acres in a rectangular form. The cemetery fronts Hamilton Lane on the east. From the northeast corner, the property line extends west, separating the cemetery from the Methodist Protestant Cemetery. The westernmost portion of the northern boundary abuts Alexandria National Cemetery, with the northwest corner lying about 100 feet west of Hooff’s Run. The southern boundary runs roughly parallel to the northern line, separating the cemetery from the Washington Street United Methodist Cemetery (Union Cemetery) and, along its western section, from property now owned by AlexRenew (formerly the Alexandria Sanitation Authority), site of its RiverRenew project.

The cemetery once extended farther across Hooff’s Run, as the 1890 survey shows. Mid-20th-century infrastructure projects and a 1994 boundary agreement with Norfolk Southern Railroad and the Carlyle development changed this part of the property. Under that settlement, the trustees donated land on the west side of Hooff’s Run for the Alexandria African American Heritage Park, and in exchange the cemetery received adjoining parcels, including the 580 and 700 Holland Lane tracts, so it still owns land on the west bank.


Landscape and Contributing Features

The cemetery is shaded by mature trees, including maples more than 100 years old, lindens planted in the mid-20th century, and a massive eastern cottonwood, estimated at more than 150 years old, on the northern edge bordering Alexandria National Cemetery. Its most notable tree is a star magnolia (Magnolia stellata) surrounded by gravestones from the 1850s to the 1890s. Recognized as a Notable–Champion (SC2) tree with a National Tree Registry score of 139, it remains healthy and carefully maintained despite its age.

Star magnolia in full bloom among 19th-century gravestones in the Presbyterian Cemetery
The star magnolia in full bloom, surrounded by gravestones from the 1850s to the 1890s. The 1903 Victorian-style front fence along Hamilton Lane is visible in the foreground.

The Victorian Gate and Enclosure

Only the seven-acre burial ground is fenced. The front section, dating to 1903, has an ornate Victorian-style wrought-iron gate with decorative scrollwork and gold lettering reading “Presbyterian Cemetery 1809”; later fencing encloses the rest. The gate remains one of the cemetery’s most recognizable features.

The 1903 black wrought-iron Victorian-style main gate of the Presbyterian Cemetery, with gold lettering reading Presbyterian Cemetery 1809
The 1903 Victorian-style wrought-iron gate at the cemetery’s entrance on Hamilton Lane.

Sexton Jerry Frazier and the Grave Robbers of 1881

For a number of years in the late nineteenth century, the cemetery’s sexton was Jeremiah H. “Jerry” Frazier, a free Black man born around 1818, who made his living as a market gardener and “vine dresser.” As sexton he opened graves and kept watch over the burial ground, which the Alexandria Gazette once called the “silent city” under his care.

On the night of January 26, 1881, grave robbers came to the Presbyterian Cemetery and took the body of Almira (Elmira) Jacobs from her grave in the Jacobs family plot. That same night they also took Frazier’s own daughter, Sarah Jane Simms, from her grave in neighboring Union Cemetery. Both women were reburied, and the story of that night, and of Frazier himself, is told in full in Grave Robbers in Alexandria: The Night the Sexton’s Daughter Was Taken.

The Jacobs family plot in the Presbyterian Cemetery, Wilkes Street Cemetery Complex, where grave robbers took the body of Almira Jacobs in January 1881.
The Jacobs family plot. Almira Jacobs lies at left, beside her father, Presley Jacobs (center), and her mother, Elizabeth (right).

Jerry Frazier died in April 1897, and his own burial place has not been found. He belongs to the long line of caretakers who have looked after this ground since 1809.


Closing Interpretation

Its trees, gate, and grave markers have become landmarks in Alexandria’s cultural landscape. The cemetery’s well-documented origins in the 1803 yellow fever epidemic, and its role in the town’s early public health reforms, add to the historical significance of the entire Wilkes Street Cemetery Complex.

Today, the Presbyterian Cemetery remains both a place of remembrance and an outdoor archive of Alexandria’s past. The more than 2,400 people buried here, from war heroes and civic leaders to merchants, ministers, and everyday citizens, each add a story to the history of the community that shaped them.

Looking for burial arrangements, visitor access, or cemetery regulations?
Visit the official site of the Presbyterian Cemetery of Alexandria →


Interested in walking through history? Join a guided tour to hear these stories, and many more, on the grounds where they unfolded.


Important Visitor Information

The Presbyterian Cemetery is a controlled-access cemetery. Before you visit, please review the visiting policies and procedures.

A map of the cemetery’s sections is available to help you locate individual graves.

Sources of Information

Published Sources

The Alexandria Association. (1956). Our Town 1749–1865. At Gadsby’s Tavern, Alexandria, Virginia. The Dietz Printing Company.

Alexandria Circuit Court. (1866). Will of Gottlieb Appich. Alexandria Will Book 8, p. 443.

Alexandria Common Council. (1804). An act reducing into one and amending the several acts respecting the removal of nuisances and the preservation of the health of the town. Alexandria Statute Book D, pp. 100–101.

Alexandria Gazette. (1881, January 27–29; February 18). Reports on the grave robberies in the Presbyterian and Union cemeteries and the hearing of the accused. Alexandria Gazette, p. 3.

Alexandria Health Office. (1803, September 14). List of burials in the different burial grounds of the town, since the 20th of August. Alexandria Advertiser and Commercial Intelligencer.

Appich, G. (1857, September 10). Reward advertisement for Townsend and Mary Derricks [Advertisement]. Alexandria Gazette, p. 1. Ran in successive issues through October 14, 1857. Retrieved from Virginia Chronicle.

Beaman, G. A. (2026). Alexandria City Hall, Market Square, and Slavery: A Documentary Study (Alexandria Archaeology Publication No. 149). Office of Historic Alexandria, City of Alexandria, Virginia.

Blanton, W. B. (1931). Medicine in Virginia in the Nineteenth Century. Garrett & Massie, Inc.

Brockett, F. L., & Rock, G. W. (1883). A Concise History of the City of Alexandria, Virginia, from 1669 to 1883, with a Directory of Reliable Business Houses in the City. Gazette Book and Job Office.

Cox, E. (1976). Historic Alexandria, Virginia, Street by Street: A Survey of Existing Early Buildings. EPM Publications.

Deneale, G., & Swift, J. (1806, June 26). [Advertisement seeking burial site for four congregations]. Alexandria Gazette. Retrieved from Newspapers.com.

Fairfax County Deed Book M2, p. 311. (1813, February 6). Deed between Philip G. Marsteller and Christiana D. Marsteller and the Trustees of the Presbyterian Congregation of Alexandria [Microfilm]. Alexandria Library, Special Collections Division, Fairfax County Deeds, Microfilm call number 00030.

Fleming, L. B., Rhodes, E. F., & Fleming, J. E. (1981). Centennial Thomas Fleming 1881–1941. AdArt.

Garrett, A. B. (1939). Survey of the Presbyterian Cemetery, updating the 1890 Howell & Greenhough plan. Alexandria, Virginia.

Gaughan, A. J. (2011). The Last Battle of the Civil War: United States Versus Lee, 1861–1883. Louisiana State University Press.

Hakenson, D. C. (2010). This Forgotten Land, Volume II: Biographical Sketches of Confederate Veterans Buried in Alexandria, Virginia. Donald Hakenson.

Hamilton, E. J. (2021). A Scottish Migration to Alexandria. Ellen J. Hamilton.

Howell & Greenhough. (1890). Survey map of the Presbyterian Cemetery. Washington, D.C. Copy held in the Presbyterian Cemetery & Columbarium Archives, Alexandria, Virginia.

Lee, C. G., Jr. (1957). Lee Chronicle: Studies of the Early Generations of the Lees of Virginia. Thomson-Shore.

Lewellen, A. (2007, February). Discovering Torthorwald, Bridekirk, and Lymekilns through John Carlyle’s Inventory. Carlyle House Docent Dispatch. Northern Virginia Regional Park Authority. Retrieved from NOVA Parks.

Madison, R. L. (2005). Walking with Washington. Gateway Press, Inc.

McGroarty, W. B. (1940). The Old Presbyterian Meeting House at Alexandria, Virginia, 1774–1874. The William Byrd Press, Inc.

Miller, T. M. (1987). Pen Portraits of Alexandria, Virginia, 1739–1900. Heritage Books.

Miller, T. M. (1991). Artisans and Merchants of Alexandria, Virginia, 1780–1820, Volume 1. Heritage Books, Inc.

Miller, T. M. (2015). Murder and Mayhem: Criminal Conduct in Old Alexandria, Virginia, 1749–1900. Heritage Books.

Moore, G. M. (1949). Seaport in Virginia: George Washington’s Alexandria. Garrett and Massie, Incorporated.

Muir, J. (1814). Death Abolished: A Sermon, Occasioned by the Sickness Which Prevailed at Alexandria during August, September, and October [1803 sermon reprinted]. Alexandria, D.C.: Samuel Snowden for Robert Gray.

Peck, G. (2015, Spring). Andrew Wales: Alexandria’s first brewer. The Alexandria Chronicle (Alexandria Historical Society), no. 2.

Pippenger, W. E. (1992). Tombstone Inscriptions of Alexandria, Virginia, Volume 1. Family Line Publications.

Province of Pennsylvania. (1992). Officers and Soldiers in the Service of the Province of Pennsylvania, 1744–1765.

Quander, R. (2021). The Quanders, Since 1684: An Enduring African American Legacy. Christian Faith Publishing, Inc.

Raines, B. (2022). The Last Slave Ship: The True Story of How the Clotilda Was Found, Her Descendants, and an Extraordinary Reckoning. Simon and Schuster.

Smith, W. F., & Miller, T. M. (2001). A Seaport Saga: Portrait of Old Alexandria, Virginia (3rd ed.). The Donning Company Publishers. (Original work published 1989.)

Still, W. (1872). The Underground Rail Road: A Record of Facts, Authentic Narratives, Letters, &c. Porter & Coates. Townsend Derrix narrative, p. 443; letter of John Delaney (Oscar D. Ball), Oswego, N.Y., p. 399.

United States Census Bureau. (1850). Slave schedule, Alexandria, Virginia [household of Gottlieb Appich]. National Archives microfilm M432.

Van Horn, H. M. (2009). The Presbyterian Cemetery, Alexandria, Virginia, 1809–2009. The Arlington Press.

Virginia Trust for Historic Preservation. (2023). Lee-Fendall House Historic Structure Report: Final Report. SmithGroup.

Wenzel, E. T. (2015). Chronology of the Civil War in Fairfax County, Part I. Bull Run Civil War Round Table.

Unpublished Works

Browne, S. H. (2023, October). The Davidson, Hulfish, and English Family Lots at the Presbyterian Cemetery, Wilkes Street Cemetery Complex, Alexandria, Virginia. Unpublished manuscript, 45 pages, including family histories, mini-biographies, and images.

Dahmann, D. C. (2022). The Roster of Historic Congregational Members of the Old Presbyterian Meeting House.

Family Papers and Manuscripts

Gibson, P. “Pete.” (n.d.). Excerpts of the Gregory Family Letters of Alexandria, Virginia, pp. 12–13, 19, and other unnumbered pages. Provided by Pete Gibson, a descendant of the Gregory family.

Pamphlets

Old Presbyterian Meeting House’s Visitor’s Guide to Alexandria’s Historic Old Presbyterian Meeting House. (n.d.). Trifold pamphlet.

Websites

Alexandria Archaeology Office of Historic Alexandria. (2010). Alexandria, a living history: Alexandria waterfront history plan. City of Alexandria, Virginia. Retrieved from the City of Alexandria.

Captain Cook Society. (n.d.). Cook’s third voyage, 1776–1780. Retrieved from the Captain Cook Society.

Christopher H. Jones Antiques. (n.d.). John Muir secretary. Retrieved from Christopher H. Jones Antiques.

Cincinnati Whig. (1838, April 25). Cincinnati Whig—Extra: Most awful steam boat accident [Broadside]. Cincinnati, Ohio. Printed Ephemera Collection, Library of Congress. Retrieved from the Library of Congress.

City of Alexandria, Virginia. (1992). Historic preservation. In Adopted 1992 Master Plan, Alexandria, Virginia. Retrieved from the City of Alexandria.

Dennee, T. (2026, August). Left Behind: Townsend and Mary Long Derricks [Facebook post]. Friends of Freedmen’s Cemetery. Retrieved August 23, 2026, from Friends of Freedmen’s Cemetery on Facebook.

Friendship Firehouse Museum. (n.d.). Firehouse information. Retrieved from the Friendship Firehouse Museum.

George Washington’s Mount Vernon. (n.d.). Ramsay’s farewell speech at Wise’s Tavern. Retrieved from Mount Vernon.

Gettysburg National Military Park. (2022, May 30). Capt. Samuel R. Johnston. From the Fields of Gettysburg [Blog]. Retrieved from the park’s official blog.

Military Images Digital. (2022). A Northern Yankee in Lee’s army [Samuel R. Johnston]. Retrieved from Military Images Digital.

Office of Historic Alexandria. (n.d.). Out of the Attic [Alexandria Times column]. Retrieved from the City of Alexandria.

Old Presbyterian Meeting House. (n.d.). Church history. Retrieved from the Old Presbyterian Meeting House.

Roberts, J. (2017, November 17). Mount Zephyr. Retrieved December 15, 2023, from William Jay’s blog.

Steamboats.org. (2019). Article about the Moselle. Retrieved from Steamboats.org.

Washingtonian. (2012, July 2). The mysteries of Washington National Cathedral. Retrieved from Washingtonian.

Page last updated: November 2026

Share on Social Media

Leave a Comment